Dreams and Disillusionment: The American Dream in The Great Gatsby

Introduction: The American Dream in the Roaring Twenties

F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby is often hailed as the quintessential American novel. It has a central focus on the American Dream. Written in 1925, the novel is set in the Roaring Twenties. It captures a time when the American Dream was at its peak. This period was fuelled by post-World War I prosperity, industrial growth and a sense of boundless opportunity. However, Fitzgerald’s portrayal of the American Dream is deeply critical, revealing the disillusionment that often accompanies its pursuit. Through the life of Jay Gatsby, the novel explores the illusions surrounding the American Dream. Gatsby seeks to join the social elite, highlighting how the dream is both alluring and ultimately unattainable.

For a more comprehensive analysis of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s most beloved novel, you can visit this article on our website.

Gatsby’s Pursuit of the Dream

At the heart of The Great Gatsby is Jay Gatsby’s relentless pursuit of his own version of the American Dream. Born into poverty as James Gatz, Gatsby reinvents himself, transforming into a wealthy and mysterious figure through sheer ambition. His extravagant parties, enormous mansion and luxurious lifestyle serve as symbols of his newfound success. They are all part of his desire to prove his worth to society. He also wants to prove his worth to Daisy Buchanan, the love of his life.

For Gatsby, the American Dream is not just about material success, but about the ability to rewrite one’s destiny. He longs to escape the limitations of his background. He wants to become a self-made man. This mirrors the promise of the American Dream. Anyone, regardless of birth or social status, can achieve greatness through hard work and determination. However, Gatsby’s wealth comes from illegal activities. It does not come from honest work. This symbolises the moral compromises people often make in their pursuit of success.

Gatsby’s dream, though, is flawed from the start. His wealth is not enough to win Daisy. She is already married to Tom Buchanan, a member of the old-money elite. Despite all his efforts, Gatsby finds that money cannot buy him love. It cannot erase his humble origins. This situation reveals the limits of the American Dream.

The Illusions of Wealth and Success

Fitzgerald uses The Great Gatsby to highlight the illusions of wealth and success that are central to the American Dream. The characters in the novel, particularly Gatsby, Tom and Daisy, are driven by the desire for wealth and status. Yet, their lives are far from fulfilled. Gatsby’s lavish parties show his deep loneliness. His longing for Daisy masks his true emotions. Tom and Daisy’s wealth provides them with comfort, but it does not bring them happiness.

Gatsby’s pursuit of wealth is driven by his desire to reclaim the past. He longs for the time when he and Daisy were in love. He believes that by becoming rich and powerful, he can recreate that perfect moment. The green light at the end of Daisy’s dock becomes a symbol of this unattainable dream. It is a beacon of hope that forever remains just out of reach.

This illusion that money can solve all problems is a fundamental critique of the American Dream. In the world of The Great Gatsby, wealth does not bring happiness or fulfillment. Instead, it brings isolation, corruption, and a sense of emptiness. The novel suggests that the pursuit of material success, when divorced from moral values or genuine relationships, leads to disillusionment.

Social Class and the Myth of Equality

Fitzgerald explores several key themes in relation to the American Dream. One is the idea of social class and the myth of equality. The novel is set in a world where class divisions are stark and unyielding. Gatsby represents the “new money” of West Egg. He earned his fortune through shady dealings. Tom Buchanan and Daisy, in contrast, represent “old money.” They come from families who have inherited their wealth and status.

Despite Gatsby’s wealth, he will never be accepted into the inner circles of the old-money elite. Tom Buchanan’s disdain for Gatsby is rooted in this unbridgeable class divide. Tom is arrogant and morally corrupt. He embodies the privilege that comes with old money. Gatsby, for all his riches, remains an outsider. This conflict exposes a key flaw in the American Dream. The idea that success is attainable for everyone, regardless of social background, is a myth. Social mobility, while theoretically possible, is still constrained by class structures that value heritage and nepotism over hard work.

Fitzgerald uses this division to highlight the limitations of the American Dream. No matter how much wealth Gatsby accumulates, he cannot fully escape his past. He also faces the judgment of those born into privilege. His pursuit of success, while admirable, is ultimately futile because it is based on the false promise of social equality.

The Dream’s Collapse: Disillusionment and Tragedy

The climax of The Great Gatsby occurs when the illusions that Gatsby has built around his life begin to unravel. In a confrontation with Tom Buchanan, Gatsby’s criminal background is revealed. Daisy, the object of his desire, chooses to stay with Tom. She decides not to run away with Gatsby. This moment signals the collapse of Gatsby’s dream. It serves as a powerful metaphor for the broader collapse of the American Dream itself.

Gatsby’s tragic end occurs with his murder at the hands of George Wilson. George mistakenly believes Gatsby is responsible for his wife’s death. This marks the ultimate disillusionment. Despite all of Gatsby’s efforts, he is left with nothing. His death is lonely and meaningless, and the people who attended his lavish parties show no interest in mourning him.

Fitzgerald underscores the futility of Gatsby’s pursuit by contrasting his tragic death with the indifference of the world around him. Nick Carraway, the novel’s narrator, is the only one who seems to grasp the full tragedy of Gatsby’s life. In the end, Nick reflects on Gatsby’s fate. He states, “So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.” This captures the sense of inevitability that haunts the novel. The American Dream is a beautiful illusion. Like Gatsby’s own dream, it is forever just out of reach. It always promises more than it can deliver.

Conclusion: Fitzgerald’s Critique of the American Dream

Through the rise and fall of Jay Gatsby, The Great Gatsby delivers a powerful critique of the American Dream. Fitzgerald presents the dream as a tantalising illusion. It promises success, happiness and fulfillment. However, it often leads to disillusionment and tragedy. The novel exposes the dark side of ambition. It reveals how pursuing wealth and status can corrupt the soul. It also isolates individuals from meaningful human connections.

For GCSE and A-Level students, the novel offers rich opportunities for analysis. Gatsby’s tragic pursuit of his dream raises essential questions about the nature of success. It also prompts us to consider the moral compromises people make in its pursuit. Moreover, Fitzgerald explores social class, inequality and the myth of the self-made man. This provides a critical lens through which to view the American Dream. The novel is not just a story of one man’s downfall. It is a broader commentary on society as a whole.

Ultimately, The Great Gatsby suggests that the American Dream, while seductive, is built on fragile illusions. In a world obsessed with wealth and superficial success, true fulfillment remains elusive. The cost of chasing the dream is often far greater than the rewards.

How Apollo Scholars can help

Book your online or in-person English Literature tutoring session bookings.

Unlock our exclusive content in our Mission Control hub.